Lustr Sazan logo Lustr SazanChandeliers and the light they give
Lighting Design

How to Zone Lighting in an Open Plan Kitchen Diner

The kitchen diner I was asked to look at last spring had eleven downlights in a neat grid across seven metres of ceiling, every one of them on a single switch beside the hall door. Cooking was fine. Everything else was not.

An open plan kitchen diner at dusk with a lit worktop strip, a pendant over the dining table and two wall lights at the sofa end

The kitchen diner I was asked to look at last spring had eleven downlights in a neat grid across seven metres of ceiling, every one of them on a single switch beside the hall door. Cooking was fine. Everything else was not. At half past eight the family sat down to eat under the same flat wash of light that had been used an hour earlier to scrub a roasting tin, and the far end of the room, where the sofa faced the garden doors, had three downlights aimed at the back of everybody's head.

That is the standard failure in an open plan room, and the fittings are rarely to blame. Those eleven lamps were decent 2700 K LEDs with a sensible beam angle. The real problem was that one circuit had been asked to serve three activities that happen at different hours and want very different amounts of light. Zoning is the fix, and almost all of the work happens on paper before anyone cuts a hole in plasterboard.

Why one ceiling grid cannot serve three activities

A worktop where you chop wants roughly 300 to 500 lux measured at the surface. A dining table wants about 150 to 200 lux, pooled over the table so the faces around it are the brightest thing anyone looks at. A sofa corner for reading or television sits comfortably at 50 to 100 lux of general light with one brighter pool of around 300 lux falling on the page.

Those three figures are too far apart to average out. Set a single grid bright enough for the worktop and the dining table lands at the same level, so the meal feels like a staff canteen. Dim the grid to suit the table and the worktop drops to something near 120 lux, which puts you back to chopping inside your own shadow. Most households then solve it with a plug-in lamp on the counter. That instinct is correct, and it is also a sign the ceiling was planned wrong. Our guide to layering light in a living room works through the same three tier idea in a room that still has walls.

Light carries a second job in a space with no internal partitions. It tells your eye where one part of the room stops and the next one starts. A table with its own pendant reads as a separate place even while you can see the hob from your chair. My grandfather used that trick in far grander rooms, where one chandelier over a long table made the rest of the hall quietly recede, and it transfers neatly to a six metre side return extension.

Draw the zones before you draw the lights

Print the floor plan at 1:50 and mark the furniture you actually own rather than the furniture in the brochure. Then write on it where you stand, where you sit, and where you walk across the room at midnight for a glass of water. Three zones plus a night route is usually the whole answer for a room under about forty square metres.

ZoneWhat happens thereTarget levelFittings that suit it
Worktop and hobStanding, chopping, reading small print on a packet300 to 500 lux at the surfaceStrip in a profile under the wall cabinets, plus downlights set about 600 mm out from the wall
Dining tableEating, homework, bills, long conversations150 to 200 lux on the tabletopOne pendant or a linear fitting, 750 to 850 mm above the tabletop
Sofa and garden endReading, television, sitting almost in the dark50 to 100 lux general, 300 lux at the pageFloor lamp, a pair of wall lights, no downlights directly overhead
Route from hall to doorsWalking through at night without waking anyone20 to 50 luxOne low output fitting or a plinth light, on its own switch

Two details on that table earn their keep. The 600 mm offset for worktop downlights keeps the beam in front of you instead of behind your shoulders, which is what causes the shadow on the chopping board. And the pendant height assumes a seated eye line of roughly 1,200 mm, so anybody opposite you sees your face rather than a glowing bulb. If the table sits parallel to an island, the spacing logic in our piece on hanging pendant lights over a kitchen island applies to both runs and keeps the two rows from reading as a muddle.

Keep the colour temperature identical across all four zones. I use 2700 K throughout a kitchen diner. Mixing 2700 K pendants with 4000 K downlights is the quickest way to make an open plan room look like two rooms that fell out with each other.

You will read almost everywhere that wiring separate circuits is an old fashioned expense, and that you should put every lamp on a smart bulb, group them in an app, and rearrange zones later from the sofa. I have watched that approach fail in enough houses to argue against it for the main lighting of an open plan room.

What goes wrong in practice

Smart bulbs still answer to the wall switch above them. Flick that switch off to save a few watts and the group goes dark and unreachable, so somebody opens the app, finds the bulbs offline, and gives up. Grouped bulbs also drift. One lamp in a run of five will sit a step behind the others after a firmware update, and a slightly uneven line of light over a worktop is more irritating than no task light at all. Then there is the honest arithmetic: nine smart bulbs at 15 to 25 pounds each costs more than the second and third circuit would have.

Where it does belong

Smart control earns its place on top of proper zoning, not instead of it. Hard wire the three or four zones so each one has a dumb, reliable switch that works when the broadband is down. Then add smart dimmer modules behind two of those plates for scenes and timers. You keep the convenience and you lose the single point of failure. The only room I would wire the other way is a rental, where you cannot touch the fixed wiring at all.

Circuits, plates and what this costs

Three lighting circuits from one ceiling rose position is a straightforward job for an electrician if the floor above is still up or the ceiling is coming down anyway. In that situation I have seen quotes of roughly 350 to 600 pounds for the extra cabling, dimmer modules and testing. Chasing new cable through a finished plastered ceiling costs two to three times that, mostly in making good, so this decision belongs in the first week of a build rather than the last.

Put the switching where people walk, which means two plates, not one. A three gang plate at the hall door and a second plate near the garden doors, wired as two way, stops the long trudge back across a dark room. Resist the temptation to go past three or four gangs on one plate. Nobody memorises six unlabelled rockers, and the usual result is that two zones never get used and the household falls back to switching everything on at once, which is where this article started.

The step worth taking this week costs nothing. Walk the room at nine in the evening with every light on, then turn off everything except the lamps near the sofa and sit there for ten minutes. The zone you miss first is the one to wire properly, and the lights you did not miss at all are the ones to leave out of the plan. More rooms, and more of the thinking behind them, sit in our lighting design section.

FAQ

How many lighting circuits does an open plan kitchen diner need?

Three as a minimum, one each for the kitchen work area, the dining table and the sitting end. A fourth for a low level night route is worth the small extra cost if the room is a through route to the garden.

Can I zone a room without any rewiring?

Partly. Plug-in floor and table lamps on separate sockets give you a usable sitting zone, and a plug-in pendant can serve a table. What you cannot fix without wiring is a bright ceiling grid that covers the whole room on one switch.

Should every zone be on a dimmer?

The dining and sitting zones benefit most, since those are the ones you want at a quarter output. Worktop lighting is used at full brightness nearly all the time, so a dimmer there is optional and I often skip it.

Does a chandelier work over a table in an open plan room?

It works well, because the table is the one spot in the room with a fixed position and no traffic passing under it. Keep the overall width to about half the table width and hang it at 750 to 850 mm above the top.

FD
Farzaneh Delacroix

Farzaneh grew up in a family of crystal chandelier makers and spent her childhood among glass drops and brass arms. She writes about chandelier styles, sizes and care.

More posts by Farzaneh

More in Lighting Design

01doorganico 084goad 3hot8 4465456 after5internprogram ahandfulofblessings ahmadpc ahomcybersecurity allodialresources annodex antiquesandperiodcollectibles aotc asianworldkashmir beedlectrics bloggertemplatefree bluefeatheragency bodyweightsolution campaign08blog carfixadvisor catstreetcollective cbstvsports cnfanspurchasing committeeof500yearsofdignityandresistance covertopsdjs cs-kaiyuangame cuestacomunicaciontotal cxoutlet dancebetgame deskgearhub destinyvillastay detectmagazine di33 diamondsteelbuildings donmo dyanadropship emarsysfinance emimattl escapechan eskitarih evautoplay everythingweddings-orlando farmzone feedviewerapp foxstudiosscratch gamevui123 gleasongrade greetingsday hacklabasu haskell iw-kaiyun jagoanproperti jilidskripsi joltbusinessfinance juegodepokergratis juegospucca kaeru-festival latestmehndidesigns lestanzediottaviano litemagazines localcommunityhero mariashebets menswheels newwebstechs1 nikkit ootheday oxigenvpn plurfitness prefetial probudgetcarpetcleaning psychicmrsmartin pyaten qvantor rejoignezlogis rexzbot riselayouts ruchin rwxqsgd5 sakaltime shibiaowang shop-bot skrtips strcoding tetapatrium topselller uneplanteartificielle vipertechcr webtech1223411 wo-kygaming yamaha-mekar yeknava yoybuysheets zenunwa yamaha-mekar jilidskripsi ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto